Table of Contents
Methods of Diamond Formation
Many people believe that diamonds are formed from the metamorphism of coal. That idea continues to be the “how diamonds form” story in many science classrooms.
Coal has rarely – if ever – played a role in the formation of diamonds. In fact, most diamonds that have been dated are much older than Earth’s first land plants – the source material of coal! That alone should be enough evidence to shut down the idea that Earth’s diamond deposits were formed from coal.
Another problem with the idea is that coal seams are sedimentary rocks that usually occur as horizontal or nearly horizontal rock units. However, the source rocks of diamonds are vertical pipes filled with igneous rocks.
Four processes are thought to be responsible for virtually all of the natural diamonds that have been found at or near Earth’s surface. One of these processes accounts for nearly 100% of all diamonds that have ever been mined. The remaining three are insignificant sources of commercial diamonds.
These processes rarely – if ever – involve coal.
1) Formation in Earth’s Mantle
Geologists believe that the diamonds in all of Earth’s commercial diamond deposits were formed in the mantle and delivered to the surface by deep-source volcanic eruptions. These eruptions produce the kimberlite and lamproite pipes that are sought after by diamond prospectors.
Most of these pipes do not contain diamond, or contain such a small amount of diamond that they are not of commercial interest. However, open-pit and underground mines are developed in these pipes when they contain adequate diamonds for profitable mining. Diamonds have also been weathered and eroded from some of these pipes. Those diamonds are now contained in the sedimentary (placer) deposits of streams and coastlines.
The formation of natural diamonds requires very high temperatures and pressures. These conditions occur in limited zones of Earth’s mantle about 90 miles (150 kilometers) or more below the surface, where temperatures are at least 2000 degrees Fahrenheit (1050 degrees Celsius) . The critical temperature-pressure environment for diamond formation and stability is not present globally. Instead it is thought to be present primarily in the mantle beneath the stable interiors of continental plates .
Diamonds formed and stored in these “diamond stability zones” are delivered to Earth’s surface during deep-source volcanic eruptions. These eruptions tear out pieces of the mantle and carry them rapidly to the surface . See Location 1 in the diagram at the top of the page. This type of volcanic eruption is extremely rare and has never been observed by modern humans.
Is coal involved? Coal is a sedimentary rock, formed from plant debris deposited at Earth’s surface. It is rarely buried to depths greater than two miles (3.2 kilometers). It is very unlikely that coal has been moved from the crust down to a depth well below the base of a continental plate. The carbon source for these mantle diamonds is most likely carbon trapped in Earth’s interior at the time of the planet’s formation or delivered to great depths by subduction.
2) Formation in Subduction Zones
Tiny diamonds have been found in rocks that are thought to have been subducted deep into the mantle by plate tectonic processes – then returned to the surface . (See Location 2 in the diagram at the top of the page.) Diamond formation in a subducting plate might occur as little as 50 miles (80 kilometers) below the surface and at temperatures as low as 390 degrees Fahrenheit (200 degrees Centigrade) . In another study, diamonds from Brazil were found to contain tiny mineral inclusions consistent with the mineralogy of oceanic crust . Others have inclusions that suggest that subducted seawater was involved in their formation .
A more recent study investigated the origin on blue, boron-containing diamonds that formed at depths as great as 400 miles (650 kilometers). These super-deep diamonds also contained inclusions indicating that they were derived from subducted oceanic crust. 
Is coal involved? Coal is not a probable carbon source for this diamond-forming process. The most likely carbon sources from the subduction of an oceanic plate are carbonate rocks such as limestone, marble, and dolomite, and possibly particles of plant debris in offshore sediments.
3) Formation at Impact Sites
Throughout its history, Earth has been repeatedly hit by large asteroids. When these asteroids strike the earth, extreme temperatures and pressures are produced. For example: when a six mile (10 kilometer) wide asteroid strikes the earth, it can be traveling at up to 9 to 12 miles per second (15 to 20 kilometers per second). Upon impact this hypervelocity object would produce an energy burst equivalent to many nuclear weapons and temperatures hotter than the sun’s surface .
The high temperature and pressure conditions of such an impact are more than adequate to form diamonds. This theory of diamond formation has been supported by the discovery of tiny diamonds around several asteroid impact sites. See Location 3 in the diagram at the top of the page.
Tiny, sub-millimeter diamonds have been found at Meteor Crater in Arizona. Polycrystalline industrial diamonds up to 13 millimeters in size have been found at the Popigai Crater in northern Siberia, Russia. 
Is coal involved? Coal could be present in the target area of these impacts and could serve as the carbon source of the diamonds. Limestones, marbles, dolomites, and other carbon-bearing rocks are more likely carbon sources than coal.
4) Formation in Space
NASA researchers have detected large numbers of nanodiamonds in some meteorites. (Nanodiamonds are diamonds that are a few nanometers – billionths of a meter in diameter.) About three percent of the carbon in these meteorites is contained in the form of nanodiamonds. These diamonds are too small for use as gems or industrial abrasives; however, they are a source of diamond material . See Location 4 in the diagram at the top of the page.
Smithsonian researchers also found large numbers of tiny diamonds when they were cutting a sample from the Allen Hills meteorite . These diamonds in meteorites are thought to have formed in space through high-speed collisions similar to how diamonds form on Earth at impact sites.
Is coal involved? Coal is not involved in the creation of these diamonds. The carbon source is from a body other than Earth.
| Erlich, E.I.; Dan Hausel, W. (2002). Diamond Deposits. Society for Mining, Metallurgy, and Exploration. pp. 74-94. ISBN 0873352130.
 American Museum of Natural History (1998). The Nature of Diamonds – Diamonds are Found on Continental Cores. American Museum of Natural History.
 American Museum of Natural History (1998). The Nature of Diamonds – Kimberlite and Lamproite. American Museum of Natural History.
 American Museum of Natural History (1998). The Nature of Diamonds – From Continental Collisions, Meteor Impacts and Star Dust. American Museum of Natural History.
 Oakes, Maureen (2003). Modeling an Asteroid Impact – Did It Kill the Dinosaurs?. Los Alamos National Laboratory. URL
 Vu, Linda (2008). Spitzer’s Eyes Perfect for Spotting Diamonds in the Sky. NASA/JPL Caltech. URL
 Tyson, Peter (2000). Diamonds in the Sky. NOVA Online. URL
 Walter, M.J. and others (2011). Diamonds Show Depth of Earth’s Carbon Cycle. Carnegie Institution for Science. URL
 Krajick, Kevin (2015). Cracking Open Diamonds for Messages From the Deep Earth. State of the Planet, Earth Institute | Columbia University. URL
 Gemological Institute of America (2018). Researchers Discover the Unique Origin of Blue Diamonds, Gemological Institute of America. URL
 The Diamond Mines of South Africa: by Gardner F. Williams; The Macmillan Company; 1902, Volume 2, page 152. URL
5) Formation on Earth’s Surface
In the 1950s, new methods of diamond formation were discovered on Earth’s surface. Scientists were able to create the temperature and pressure conditions needed to create diamonds in a lab. Most of the early diamonds were not gem quality, but they were perfect for use as abrasive granules in drill bits, cutting tools, and grinding wheels. Soon larger lab-grown diamonds were being manufactured for use as wear-resistant bearings, heat sinks for computer processors, and high-temperature windows.
Today almost all of the diamonds used in industrial processes are lab-created diamonds. They are also being made in high enough qualities to earn colorless and very very slightly included grades from diamond grading labs. They are made in a spectrum of colors by adding nitrogen (yellow) or boron (blue) to the diamond-forming environment. Green, pink, orange and other colors are possible with post-growth treatment processes. Lab-created diamonds are being made in the United States and several other countries. China is the leading country producing lab-created diamonds.
All lab-grown diamonds are made using equipment that consumes an enormous amount of electricity, which is needed to create the temperature and pressure conditions necessary to grow diamonds. Some of that electricity is likely to be generated from burning coal. These might be the best examples of diamonds being made using coal.
|“I have frequently been asked, “What is your theory of the original crystallization of the diamond?”
“All that can be said is that in some unknown manner carbon, which existed down deep in the internal regions of the Earth, was changed from its black and uninviting appearance to the most beautiful gem which ever saw the light of day.”
Gardner F. Williams, General Manager of De Beers Consolidated Mines, Ltd., 1887 to 1905. 
Burying the Coal Formation Idea
The most convincing evidence that coal did not play a role in the formation of most diamonds is a comparison between the age of Earth’s diamonds and the age of the earliest land plants.
Most of the rock-hosted diamond deposits that have been found were formed during the Precambrian Eon – the span of time between Earth’s formation (about 4,600 million years ago) and the start of the Cambrian Period (about 542 million years ago). In contrast, the earliest land plants did not appear on Earth until about 450 million years ago – nearly 100 million years after the formation of the vast majority of diamonds that have been mined.
Since coal is formed from terrestrial plant debris, and the oldest land plants are younger than almost every diamond that has ever been dated, it is easy to conclude that coal did not play a significant role in the formation of Earth’s natural diamonds.
Find Other Topics on Geology.com: